Wednesday, September 14, 2005

Times of a Tabloid

Ad-verse Condition
"Al-Qaida in Kanpur, selling Insurance !" screamed the thursday's Times of India edition like it had ants in its pants, a few months ago. Turns out to be just an advertizing gimmick by an insurance company in UP, which the Times reporter covered.
I can't believe the extent of stupidity this paper has managed to amass in recent years. From a once respected daily, it has now turned into a novice tabloid. Who else in their right mind can take this crap as "News" ! ... The paper obviously is trying very hard to please its readers, by talking their talk, but unfortunately for it, this simply isn't the right direction.

Megalomaniac
The paper tries so hard to please its readers that it's simply amazing the extent to which it goes to lick each one of it's readers boots. All the more evident in the way it gives cricket a prized place in its sports section. Agreed it has a popular following here, but who the hell wants to know which cricketer had what food for the day, when in wimbledon all hell was breaking loose. Just going through a few editions when chapell was named coach will give one a very good idea of what TOI is up to. "chapell did this", "chapell ate that", "chapell swam here" "chapell kicked there".... man !! who in their right mind would be interested in an old man's daily routine !

Critical Nonsense
The only thing TOI is good at is to sensationalize crappy news, make people believe that the news they get from TOI is indeed of critical importance to them, with most of the news sounding more like as though a convicted lunatic is walking around in the neighbourhood with missiles tied to his shorts ! Only after we have read the full dumb story that it becomes clear that it's actually a kid's who's been running around with two unusually long pencils in his pocket, and then followed by a long boring story about bringing up kids without the aid of pencils ! That's news !, courtesy: TOI.

Many a times , i feel, TOI is majorly responsible for all that euphoria it creates about players, movies, cricket or all those stuff which turn out to be a damp squib.

Whacky Whacks
The dumbness of the paper is only equalled by an even more pathetic way in which it tries to lure people by their so called 'whacky' one liners. For instance, their world news section is now named "The World at your Feet"....tell me, does this even remotely make sense ? Even a drunk hyena would agree that this is the act of a bafoon. Or the first page one liner printed above the name of the paper, which says "Zero Worries. Zero Duties. Celebrations Unlimited"....duh !. Even a baby that can't sit on its potty properly has a million worries, and these guys talk like they are publishing for readers on MARS to read it.

Poll position
Anyone familiar with the so called Poll section of the TOI will agree with me on the kind of questions that are put up for poll. I usually read that section of the paper when i feel this intense urge to barf; works for me. Many a times it makes me wonder if TOI employs people in its ruddy office to actually participate in those polls. Insane questions more like "Do you think Aishwarya should have slapped salman ?" or even worse "Is Bill Gates ready for Pearly Gates ?" keep readers guessing...astoundingly, many a times there is only a "Yes" and a "No" for the reader to choose from, when most of the time its "can't say" which is the answer ! how can a midget sitting in Domlur know why Aishwarya chose to do what she did !
Well any roadside hawker will tell you that this is a cheap gimmick to find out how many people read their paper along with increasing the sms traffic, and then finally publish one fine day that it's nearest rival "The Deccan Herald" had to eat it's shoes for trying to compete with it. Anyway, both these newspapers bring out ads against each other, which more or less looks like two hungry mongrels trying to bite into each other's tail.

Unnerving Dubya
Of Course the most celebrated crap about TOI are its reporters and it columnists. It's long time loyalist The-Pin-head-Poop-Brain Jug Suraiya should have actually starved of hunger like one of those somalia UNICEF baby ads, but for TOI. Who in the right mind would give him a job otherwise. His infamous Dubyaman cartoon strip was such a pain to read, it used to bring me back those childhood nightmares of "goggayya"(Devil with a banjo), which that long lost aunty used to tell me to put me to sleep. I still remember the curses readers used to send(which the TOI had the nerve to publish right below the cartoon) every damn day, and almost plead it to remove that cartoon strip. Half of pin-head's hairs must have fallen off because of those curses. One reader had almost threatened to create a rival comic strip in Deccan Herald, while another wrote "I like to read the curses people send, more than the cartoon itself, so please keep up the work" :D....As for me, i used to read that strip whenever i felt threatened that i was the last fool left on the face of the earth, and console myself that i was wrong.

Caste-ing a bait
A few months ago, an ad for their matrimonial edition, on the front page of the paper shouted "We openly discriminate among people. We support people who advertize in our matrimonial service with the words caste no bar in their ad, by providing a 10% discount"... i mean this is sordid stuff....Does the Times of India think it is some neo-secularist, out to rid the society of caste and prejudice ? i would laugh my head out if someone told me "yes"...It is just a pathetic way, chosen by the paper, to get popular following with it's pseudo-secular views. Agreed there are problems with systems in a society, but everything has a way to be dealt with. Times of India is no full of saints who have given up their happiness for the cause of people. It has always been a sack full of dirty vagabonds who eat into the society by exploiting its weakness.

Ad-vantage
Added to this, the paper is filled with ads, so much so that we have to virtually search for news. Look at the creativity of the advertizers, they publish their ads that look like news columns; only after we have read it completely we come to know that it is a solicitation by a plumbing company asking us to buy "Ashok pipes" !...Darn this paper ! one day they'll publish a small sheet of paper which will tell the pages and columns in which news can be found in their newspaper for that day !.

Sleezy Solace
What was once a Information supplement, the Bangalore Times has now turned into one that is a sleezy compliment. Well another paper "Asian Age" was born that way, but TOI didn't think twice before turning into one either. Starting from those putrid "15 questions to keep your wife happy", to "5 easy ways to separate from each other", TOI has printed a whole load of elephant dung in the past years. None make sense, especially those silly quizzes which evaluates nothing more than the amount of mental crap that readers have acquired over the years reading this damned news paper.

In its attempt to appeal to the younger generation, TOI goes one step ahead by buying itself a medallion of foolishness, apart from being an accomplished street fool. Many a times, the paper itself has no idea what its printing, and keeps publishing the same rabid stuff again and again in different pages, hoping people will not find out.

Of course the limited creativity that its crew possesses is hardly usable, so they print stuff that hardly leaves anything to the reader's creativity or imagination.

The Times did shine
Once a Bhel-puri guy was particularly happy about TOI, my rants notwithstanding, "Saar ee times auf india nouru super . ond rupai kotre, 1 kg paper kodthaare, ond dinakke asht saaku" (The Times of India guys are too good, for 1 rupee they give a kg of paper, enough for me to sell bhel-puri to customers for 1 full day)

Needless to say, i stopped respecting TOI a long time ago, but i do read it once in awhile to see if it has broken records in steeping even lower. Until now the TOI has not failed me in accomplishing that. Atleast they are good at that !

24 Comments:

Blogger Suneel said...

I liked your Point Of View, and I have the same opinion about it. I still wonder you didnt mention an entire section of PAGE 3 and Thursday's and friday's Last page in Bangalore Times.

TOI still contains most vulgar pictures of people who are partying. Why the HELL we should about them. I dont know how those parties are adding values to countries growth or people's thinking, but its definitely introducing wrong thinking among young generation.

Worst thing is about celebrities, Even if they wake up, TOI makes a big news out of it and prints it on PAGE 3.

Wed Sep 14, 11:54:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

yeah, i should have mentioned about that stuff more....again, TOI pretty slyly tries to look like its one of those younger gen kinda paper, but more or less settles down to being a bogey picker...

heehehe, and yeah its true that TOI blows up even small a mediocre occuring when it comes to celebrities...very irritating really

Wed Sep 14, 12:05:00 PM PDT  
Blogger Kiran said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

Wed Sep 14, 05:54:00 PM PDT  
Blogger Kiran said...

One point which irks me the most about wretched TOI is the website that TOI guys have. ITS Far worse than a P*** site.The number of popups that come up can hang any browser. Infact i even felt like hanging myself on one occasion. With so many things happening world wide like tsunami and mumbai rains the headline on one of those days was "Mallika rocks Cannes" and the second headline was "delhi public school part 2 surfaces".

Well written though. Loved some of the references used.
Keep writing

/Kiran

Wed Sep 14, 10:39:00 PM PDT  
Blogger ashwini bharadwaj said...

jaggs, TOI could even come up with an idea of publishing this post of yours in one of their columns, probably readers' grievances! watch out for the same.

their only supplement that is sensible is Wednesday's times ascent...we still need that at times :-)

Thu Sep 15, 02:01:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Agree!

Although, I don't think TOI is at blame alone. Indian media on a whole is. I mean, sat at US or Europe other than the shitty online TOI which other online paper is available reliable and is informative... yes TOI is crap. It’s still a better one to go for.

In no comparison with others, TOI is shitty by itself agree. Yea it is humiliating to see marriage bureau adds popping up while reading it at office …and my colleague stares at me and thinks 'he said he is getting married. the dates are out. i didn’t know he's still looking for the bride. These Indians …phew!' it's also sickening to see these 'transfer money to India' adds in there. Its like a porn site by looks.

The Indian media are on a whole as yet not responsible enough. I mean, take the recent ex of cricket match fixing enquiry. i came across the hype in the past few days TOI and now this in TOI today -

"ICC chief executive Malcom Speed dismissed the media reports as totally inaccurate and without foundation on Wednesday. "We do not normally comment on the operational activities of the ICC Anti-Corruption and Security Unit but in light of the volume of utterly unfounded reports relating to the recent tri-series in Zimbabwe it is important to make it clear that there is no investigation being undertaken into this series," he said.

"It is disappointing to see such wild and unfounded accusations circulating in the media and we have taken the unusual step of commenting on this speculation as we do not wish the reputation of the sport, the teams or the players to be tarnished by utterly inaccurate media reports," he added.”

OK lets have a laugh. Who else can give us this fun! Utter crap is init.

Take the bbc and London papers for comparison. Cricket has been a dead sport in England. Now with Ashes this year, the whole lot of them here are talking cricket even from before England won it. Thanks to media. Metro a famous daily at London paged all main columns abt Ashes, and so did the telly and all other media cos they wanted to bring cric back to life. That’s responsible media.
Ok immediately, look what TOI did - http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/articleshow/1231527.cms - “Ashes had Indian connection” Go to the details - Hilarious isn’t it? What a claim to make…

Anyway i think we should ridicule the Indian media on a whole. They are yet to grow responsible. ...Good post for that matter mate!

k!

Thu Sep 15, 04:07:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

kiran: you are right about the damn website...its really silly the way those pop-ups keep coming up...also its lack of sensitivity to news, and just worried about masala stuff is sickening.

ashwini:
hehehe :D...good one...hopefully the TOI will get something out of it :D...Ascent is pretty decent, i agree.

Thu Sep 15, 07:37:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

pj, yeah there isn't much of a choice for us when it comes to newspapers. however, it is the insistance of TOI to continue with crap, inspite of being told a million times not to, is what is very irritating.

And that blowing up of small things is very characterstic of TOI, that ICC example proves that well.
The funny things TOI comes up with sometimes, incredulous i must say. The other day, there was a headline news in the paper which said "Kannadiga rulers ruled up to the land of krishna" or somethign like that...based on the bone of a dog which had sword marks of some rulers down south....or some crap like that..no basis nothing, just some mental reporter from TOI who thought he might as well drink and write, since it makes no difference anyway !
The way they kept supporting Sonia for PM, it was just pathetic....the paper was stinking like crazy...the level it can stoop to make itself look as though it was secular is unimaginable....really

Thu Sep 15, 07:46:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Manu Gurudatha said...

Yeah.... the absolute irritation starts right when u press 'Enter', and a thousand pop ups fill ur screen... juggi, I think you have almost covered all other aspects neatly... may be newspapers are loosing importance now (similar to how it is in US... newspapers are synonymous to ad-papers)

Thu Sep 15, 11:21:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Akshay said...

There used to be a time when TOI was a craze as a kid.. thanks to NIE
I still remember I was subscribing for TOI in my school while at my house it was Indian Express.. Ofcourse news for what I wanted at that age was a lil different...
TOI is clearly here to make money by selling some pulp news. If you have understood what Gail Wynand stood for in Fountainhead, TOI embodies him. They sell news that the 'average' common man wants to read. And trust me most of them would not read what you have missed in TOI...

On a business perspective, TOI is all right in what shit they are selling people. They are driven by people in that aspect. In fact, I had a similar argument with boda.. he said newspaper has a duty to public.. I still disagree on that count... As a reader, I would never want to read TOI for most critical news.. I know it now ..thus I have no qualms with it... But why is it any wrong in what they sell? Aren't we to blame ourselves to buy it???
I read cnn.com and news.google.com and when I feel bugged of work and need to lighten I visit TOI to read up stuff on 'how a man slept with his neighbour who happened to be a guy' kinda stories..
I still stand by the fact that I find nothing wrong in TOI, 'cause I dont care for news from them...
yeah MOST DEFINITELY their website is a piece of shit....

Thu Sep 15, 03:44:00 PM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

For somebody who has been brought up on a diet of DeccanHerald, I can't fathom the kind of columns the TOI carries. But I love TOI only on Wednesdays though:) TOI is caught in a catch-22 situation whether to go the tabloid way or to remain a daily.

Thu Sep 15, 08:02:00 PM PDT  
Blogger Supreeth Subramanya said...

Oooohhh mmy godd (that's Janice for you - I've started with F.R.I.E.N.D.S again!),an awesome blog entry kano, Juggs. Your argument is very analytical and supported by an array of illustrations, the language is very mature and thoughts are conveyed very crisply. I give you a score of 5 out of 6 (because that's what I got in GRE analytical :-)).

On the subject matter itself, I don't understand why you're so irritated with TOI sitting in US. I agree that you're a responsible Indian Citizen, but I'm certain that you are not a good sample of the average-reader-of-Indian-english-daily set. Hence you don't have much rights to comment on what they choose for their diet.

When you've graduated from this level, you should get going and let the lower mortals enjoy what they want. This reminds me of my father's long-standing complaint towards contemporary cinema that there aren't any good mythological/social movies being made these days. My god! who the hell will watch it? May not be a totally appropriate anology, but I'm sure you would've got my intentions.

I don't think it is wise to fight/revolute if you're not in majority. Get going and create a new brand, if you're powerful enough and if you see a void - I'm sure there'll be lot of takers for it. One classic example I can think of is Rangashankara of Bangalore.

Thu Sep 15, 08:54:00 PM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Supreeth, I read TOI online daily. I don't exactly get what you mean because location doesn't change the identity of a person. Had I been a journalist what you've said would pinch in more, but I don't get why a end reader expecting to get news from India, although sat abroad, should not expect reliability n quality and if he did, should make conscious effort to improve things himself.
Freedom to speech and criticism is one of the best tools we can deploy to bring in improvements in any area.

I think TOI online is there only for the US NRI's and it's still there cos of the US NRI's. The fund flow is from there. Of course they can demand quality.

- is my argument.

- what say?

k!

Fri Sep 16, 01:45:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Aah! Since I'm from the media, let me tell you TOI bashing is the in-thing among everybody and their neighbours. Including the media. All of us have been there, done that, cursed, never-want-to-work-with times blah blah and blah blah! but the end of the day, people buy, read and importantly pay for it. Piddly amounts, at that,so who complains? not even the channa-walla :) In fact, here in Mumbai, we're getting over a 100 pages of times (yeah my god, we need it hehe!) along with a "Broadloid" (Mumbai Mirror -- between times and a tabloid format) to go with the "broadsheet" thats the times. It's full of soft porn, on how to have good sex every single day (I'm telling you complain they might, but people read only that in MM) I for one would like to say maybe an Express, or here in Mumbai, even a DNA (Daily News and Analysis) is giving them a run for their money. Even crappy, HT in Delhi has toned down in Mumbai, to give times a little shake. Boy, and scared they are, of losing market share. Coz people like you and me, still question thankfully. The Hindu is the other extreme, but I guess we need to live with all kinds of media. :) U know what, I often think, as I'm in the insider ring, sometimes we do tend to underestimate the readers :) and often pass off crap in the name of a decent report. Honestly speaking, just like every research analyst or consultant, or even marketing guys, we use templates :) and I'm not kidding. every year, if you have the time to notice, you'd see a similar odd story or two by the same reporters, around times like diwali, or ganpathi, or on a more corporate note, results season etc etc :) But that's digressing. Times = crap in the name of news. From this side of the fence, best paymasters. I guess, with more competition they'd just get sillier, and trust me, ask any of the lot and they'll say "this is what our readers want to read, so up yours!" Lets not even get into the madness of television! So much for good journalism :)

Fri Sep 16, 07:03:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

Deepa, Agree with you that lots of papers do tend to cater to what the general public wants. The problem however is the classic case of Demand-Supply and Supply-Demand dilemma. Unless people are provided with quality material, no one knows if there will be a demand for that.
I believe that any responsible Newspaper or other media should not entangle itself in petty competition, and instead focus on delivering news that is news. Of course, the cross section of the society that reads newspapers is varied, and this is where the rookie is seperated from the professional vis-a-vis media.

It's true that media tries to stuff people with what they want. again we would put the blame on people-which is partly true too, but then this again assumes that the 'Majority' is always right. My Earlier post "Bollywood Trash" talks about the same thing, and many have commented that hindi movies are made the way they are cause people like to see it the way they are. Which means movies like "mein hoon na" and serials like "sause bhi bahut thi" will still be made, and people will still popularise it. killing creativity was never more easier.

Like you mentioned, media in general underestimate people, and until a few years back, it could get away with such stuff. Its not true anymore, but the funny thing is illiteracy seems to have been a big bane for the concept of "majority wins".

it is not just in media and entertainment, it happens in our industry too. Well that is another big story, told one at a time :D...

hopefully this is just a phase and things might change for the better...

Fri Sep 16, 09:59:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

manu: u r right about the US newspapers. atleast the one i get here in NJ, called the Daily News is almost 70 pages, and half of it looks like that "admag" thing that is printed in india. its even worse on sundays, almost 150-200 pages...with lots of small books in it too !....the first time i went ot pick up a paper on a sunday, i thought they had mixed the whole weeks newspapers, only to realise that all were for sunday alone !

Fri Sep 16, 10:20:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

akku: :D..yeah, even i remember those days when NIE used to be a fad. We used to have this friday last period clubs, and newspaper reading was one of them. The only thing they did was read newspaper, easy timepass :D..and NIE had this concept of 3 people sharing, or 2 or 1 remember. The 3-guys groups were a mess :D...most used to read stale news that was stale anyway :D..

That apart, i am not sure if i'd like to agree with the idea that TOI or any other published paper is only good for entertainment, and not for serious stuff. That way, even google news could be junk since it retrieves news from other papers, and cnn gives the outside perspective instead of just reporting news, especially in case of asia.

I cannot agree on the idea that business should play a major part in news, then it would be a huge disaster, then there would be no need for freedom of speech or news reporting. Media would just support whom they want and print what they like, can't it ? precisely what TOI did when Sonia almost became PM, by printing rabid stuff about other parties, and glorifying congress.

Media has a lot of influence on people, and it is important that the right things come out. why else is the need for china to strictly control media ? misconception most often is the first seed for revolt.

Fri Sep 16, 10:34:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

Supreeth: first congrats maadko analytical 5/6 = level score :D.

As for whether i can comment sitting here in another country about a paper in india, my take on that is exactly what pj has explained. I have been in india all my life, excpet for the last one month ! and most likely i am still as much a banglorean as i was before leaving bangalore :D...
Also, i read the online e-paper of TOI [ ;)) ], which is a photocopy of what is printed in bangalore, so i can't be wrong about the details in it.
hence i am in my rights...it might have been wrong for me to comment if i was not part of that society, not otherwise.
Nor can i agree about 'lower mortals' idea....does that mean that people who arent graduates are OK with reading crap on paper ?

again Movies based on Social issues or mythology go on to be great hits, if made well. any movie for that matter. "Gladiator", "Troy" are all mythology. I to this day consider "Mahabharata" serial as one of the best every made. The cast, the acting, direction was simply amazing. "Black" wasn't a movie i liked for reasons of direction, but it was a hit, so directors dabbling with social issues dont always bite the dust.
Again, it is what you want to show and how you show that matters, and not bound by generation or what people like. in fact it is the other way round.

:D..you are very much aware of how much i am against the concept of "Majority Wins" which i consider is silly and often short-sighted.

But i do agree with you on the void stuff, a pretty good point, and yeah rangasharkara is a good example for that. if i could alone make a difference in every field then nothing like it, but i do believe that people in every field must be open to ideas and criticism, and adapt it, instead of expecting the person who comments to do it for them.

Fri Sep 16, 11:02:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

pj: agree with you on most of what you have written.

Fri Sep 16, 11:04:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hey jagdish dude....send yer blog to the so called "editors" of TOI.
Having lived in blore for 24 years, I see the change in the news content of TOI...oops hang on...what news ???
BANGALORE TIMES....man what in the world is this shitty supplement?
the news is only about various parties held at different clubs n pubs..hosted by the "socialites" of blore...my A$$...its jus a bunch of freakin rich people who seem to have all the time in the world to drink on all days of the week...n they are supposed to be the coolest crowd of bangalore...hate this...the blore times supplemnet shud be christened " SLEAZY TIMES " or "BINGE TIMES"...
i think there a set of wannabe cool people in blore..everytime they host a party,they call up these jobless ediotrs at TOI n ask them to write about their worhtless parties....i wish i can bash up these editors sometimes....the worst part is that these people are called the FACE OF BANGALORE!!!
I wish i can use more expletives here..am i allowed jagdish ???

more later

Wed Sep 21, 03:23:00 PM PDT  
Blogger Jagadish said...

hmmm....i can see why you are angry, and rightly so. It's not a very great feeling when times just puts on some party pictures and says it's the "face of bangalore". it's disheartening to see TOI resorting to such stuff.

Fri Sep 23, 06:16:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

good work. to me hindu rules, biased or non-biased.

Mon Apr 17, 08:41:00 AM PDT  
Blogger Neeraja said...

I know the timing of my comment comes when TOI is probably at its worst... but i know they will out-Worsen themselves very soon!

I didnt even get this "news" on any major american newspaper! http://tinyurl.com/7lob5k8 way to go Times of India - time to rename it to CineMasala?...

Maybe they should buy "behind the woods" or something and operate solely as a cheap gossip tabloid I will atleast have more respect for them if they dont parade around calling themselves a major newspaper!

Fri Nov 18, 11:37:00 AM PST  
Blogger Neeraja said...

I know the timing of my comment comes when TOI is probably at its worst... but i know they will out-Worsen themselves very soon!

I didnt even get this "news" on any major american newspaper! http://tinyurl.com/7lob5k8 way to go Times of India - time to rename it to CineMasala?...

Maybe they should buy "behind the woods" or something and operate solely as a cheap gossip tabloid I will atleast have more respect for them if they dont parade around calling themselves a major newspaper!

Fri Nov 18, 11:38:00 AM PST  

Post a Comment

<< Home